I’ve found a large number of subjects that I’m fairly interested in, but at the end of the day the most interesting essay that I’ve wrote to date has been on Indigenous Participation in World War One. I wrote it in my second year at Okanagan College and it was quite eye openning and I have since wanted to do more research on the subject but the subject fits very awkwardly into a crossroads of historical analysis, indigenous activism and indigenous studies in general. There’s both informal and academic measures that need to be taken to better understand this topic.
The first thing I want to clarify is that people are not unaware of Indigenous participants. It’s something that everyone knows, but the thing that I find most interesting is how nobody talks about it. During all these discussions on Truth and Reconciliation, nobody talks about Indigenous Veterans. The fact of Indigenous participation in both world wars and other military operations might be overlooked as a Canadian citizen simply doing their duty but there are a couple complicating factors to that narrative in particular which deal with Indian status, Indian soveriegnty, racism and government relations.
Indian Status:
When thinking about Indian Status in relation to war participation, it is commonly recognized that minors should not go to war. The definition of minor is a changing one, depending on where in history you are at it could range from anywhere between 8 and 18/19 years old. How does that relate to Indigenous participation one might ask? Status Indians were legally in a state of perpetual adolescents under the wardship of the Canadian Government. This renders Indigenous people in a perpetual state of legal minority. Of course, this did not stop Indian Affairs from seeking enlistment in reserves, or many Indigenous joining out of their own imperative.
Indian Sovereignty:
This brings me to Sovereignty; Indigenous people sought participation for a number of reasons and a lot of it came down to asserting sovereignty in one form or another or seeking recognition from the government to address their grievances. The Haudenosaunee Confederacy in particular should be noted as both having significant participation on their own imperative, but also seeking recognition from the British Royalty in acknowledging the historic alliance between the Haudenosaunee and the British Royalty that began with the Covenant Chain in the 17th century. Indian Agents refused to even forward a message to the Canadian Government, let alone a message straight to the British Royalty.
Racism and Government Relations:
These two go hand in hand, which must be recognized. As discussed about the Haudenosaunee and the interference of Indian Agents, this is seen throughout the nation as Indigenous peoples attempted to use participation or lack of participation as a means to get the attention of the Canadian Government. More often than not I summerize that they are ignored. It does not end there: Returning Indigenous veterans were not given the same benefits of non-Indigenous veterans and some were not even able to return to their reserves. Some indigneous people had to abandon their reserves and/or their traditional territories as they lost half their population from more than 100% of eligable participants being sent overseas and only 3% of those returning as veterans. Of course this scenario isn’t common, but it was one of the outcomes for indigenous participants.
I cannot even say I’m happy with my research or the current state of research on this subject in particular. Indigenous Participation in World War Two is largely understudied with only one monograph (book) on depictions of Indigenous soldiers during World War Two being the only accessible (this does not account for the possibility of graduate theses or other studies done by students that go unpublished) study available to date. If a reader finds this topic in particular intriguing, this is the topic in particular that I wish to do my graduate research on and wish to use this topic to better illuminate the relationship between Canadian and Indigenous governments across Canada.
The Statement of Indigenous Participation
As Unique as the Tribes
Alexander George Rousseau
Hist 206-001 Aboriginal Settler Relations
November 27, 2016
Participation in World War I had given Canada a platform to become an independent nation; within Canada indigenous communities used participation in World War I and World War II in a similar manner. It was until 1960, after World War II, when Status Indians gained the right to vote. Status Indians were considered wards of the state by the Canadian Government, and in a permanent state of adolescence. Furthermore, Minister of Militia Sam Hughes issued an order forbidding the recruitment of Indian Soldiers during World War I, to protect them from the Germans who may not treat them humanely in warfare. This order only applied to a single recruiting district and was ignored as the war progressed1. Yet in World War I alone over 4000 Indians were reported enlisting (this did not include Metis, Non-Status or Inuit recruits) which was estimated as being 35% of the male military aged population of Indians across the nine provinces2. Duncan Campbell Scott, the Deputy Superintendent General of Indian Affairs, wrote a report that glorified Indian Enlistment to the Canadian Government. Scott reflected on the Indians willingness to “give their lives for their country without compulsion or even the fear of compulsion,” and further note that some Indians were unacquainted with English and therefore unable to understand the reasons for the war3. Lackenbauer draws attention to this as making indigenous enlistment remarkable4. Remarkable as it was, indigenous enlistment was not without purpose, as the indigenous soldiers’ reasons for enlistment varied nearly as much as their non-indigenous counterparts, but each reason reflected indigenous struggles upon their return as they attempted to reaffirm themselves as citizens in a country that neglected them.
Indigenous soldiers who went to the war to reconnect with their marital spirituality and tradition came to represent the rekindling of First Nations pride in Canada that began a movement for social justice for the indigenous people. Indigenous soldiers such as Francis Pegahmagabow and Mike Mountain Horse used enlistment to rekindle lost values as warriors and connections to their ancestors. Francis Pegahmagabow’s enlistment was to reconnect with his ancestors and carry on their traditions5. Pegahmagabow was from a hereditary line of chieftains in the Parry Island First Nations, and saw enlistment as a requirement to becoming a leader like his grandfather6. Thus, when war broke out Pegahmagabow enlisted to fulfil his spirit quest that affirmed his position as chief. During the war the white Anglican environment offered little comfort to the indigenous soldiers and they pursued comfort in their own traditions which were banned, lost, or forgotten by many. Mike Mountain Horse, a member of the Blackfoot who had many of their martial traditions outlawed in their treaties, found his personal war song in the trenches. The song represented one step of becoming a man to The Blackfoot who viewed participation in the warpath as a coming of age ritual7. Similarly, Pegahmagabow took great comfort in his wadijigan during the war, which connected him to his manidos, or spiritual guardian8. In Jeffery Williams memoir, as a white World War II veteran, also observed how the indigenous soldiers reveled in their traditional songs and dances in private9. Pegahmagabow, Mountain Horse and other indigenous soldiers rediscovered a powerful faith in their culture in the trenches, which they took back to Canada and their tribes. Francis returned empowered, reconnected with his spirituality. He became an activist, becoming an advocate about the unequal treatment from the government compared to his white brothers in arms, who had grown to respect their indigenous counterparts greatly10. Reverend Edward Ahenakew attempted to rally people behind the new spirit found in the war, and that the First Nations people deserved rights as full citizens. Mountain Horse continued upon this rhetoric later stating that First Nation participation was “sufficient proof of their right to be called British subjects”11. The returning warriors who were introduced to the world beyond their reserves and their rekindled spirituality and pride started a movement for First Nations equality and suffrage.
Despite this pride in their veterans, Mountain Horse and Pegahmagabow acted as visible minorities for their people as vocal spiritual veterans. Although indigenous soldiers found great comfort in their own cultures while immersed in a hostile foreign environment, economic motivations are observed as a major part of indigenous enlistment. During World War I, Indigenous men from remote and poor reserves were often more likely to enlist in greater proportions compared to those situated close to white communities that had industry that could employ indigenous people. Enlistment offered an income that eclipsed wages that the First Nations could earn otherwise, generally working for trading companies in remote areas of Canada12. This proclivity for the remote and poor reserves to be more proportionally represented in enlistment then their more urban counterparts continued into World War II. Recruitment officials reminded Indigenous peoples of the special benefits of enlisting, such as the Dependants Allowance13. Following the depression, military services guaranteed wages for indigenous people and their families who had minimal contact with the greater economy.
After World War II, the security afforded by the military wages and benefits would not continue for Indigenous veterans and their families. A veteran acknowledged that they returned home to a family that showed signs of stability14. Upon returning, veterans were given extensive social benefits under the Veterans Charter to ease the transitional period of wartime to peace15. The Veterans Charter was generous, but it assumed a level of development and stability prior to the war to benefit from it entirely. Most indigenous were not established at all and their enlistment into the war was because of their economic instability. To exacerbate the situation, the agents of the demobilization often did not provide indigenous veterans with the information required to take advantage of all the benefits allotted for veterans under the Veterans Charter16. Although generous the Veterans Charter did not address the economic instability of the indigenous veterans, and they returned to situations as poor as before.
Economics does not account for those that left successful farms and stable lives without the urging of conscription. 24 out of 38 men of age from the Fire Hills Colony in Saskatchewan left their farms to enlist. Robert J. Talbot would attribute this, at least partially, to sense of attachment to the crown, as they recently signed their treaties17. In Ontario, The Six Nations maintained that they were an independent nation and maintained that they were allies of the British Crown, not Canada, and would only officially endorse the war if the British Crown requested them to join the war18. The Six Nations attempted to use the war as Canada did, as a means of political dialogue with another nation to try and assert their sovereignty which they had never officially forfeited19. Enlistment from the Six Nations was not meeting Canadian expectations because the Canadian government refused to accommodate the Six Nation requests to open a dialogue with the British Crown, as this recognized their sovereignty. The chiefs did not endorse the war, but 292 Six Nations men enlisted. Many would be members of militia units such as the 37th Haldimand Rifles, notably a great-grandson of Joseph Brant, Cameron Brant enlisted immediately20. Cameron likely found inspiration in his great-grandfather. The enlistees were actively discouraged by their community leaders, and many were actively engaged in agriculture or otherwise employed, but most that enlisted volunteered shortly upon enlistment opening. Although it is impossible to pin any one reason upon the enlistees, Cameron Brant is an example that likely many Iroquoians related to. The Iroquoians had a long history of fighting with the British as allies, and despite what the chiefs officially stated, members of the Six Nations saw enlistment as aiding their ally in a war.
Although there were a variety of reasons for enlistment, the lack of participation, or minimal participation was often used as an attempt to get the government’s attention. Duncan Campbell Scott’s report, which glorified the participation of natives across the nine provinces, he left those that resisted participation unobserved in his report. The Department of Indian Affairs manipulated some First Nations bands to make donations, but 500 communities did not support the war with council funds at all21. Many of the First Nations used their donations as an excuse to avoid sending their men to the front lines in accordance to the early propaganda by Herbert Ames: “if you can’t put the I in fight, put the pay into patriotism”22. The chiefs at Manitoulin Island resisted enlistment, but fearing Indian Affairs deposing them they complied and attached conditions to their compliance. The chief at Wikwemikong First Nation demanded money from the government for socials works in his community as compensation for going to war23. Although these chiefs complied other communities resisted. Some communities in British Columbia resisted strongly, Duncan Campbell Scott reported that the “British Columbia are somewhat less warlike in character than those of the plains and in the eastern provinces” and further claiming their culture led them to an aversion of leaving their homes24. This does not sound like the people that would threaten violence if recruitment officers came to their lands25. British Columbian First Nations had a great amount of outstanding grievances, on top of many communities being remote and destitute, such as the Crown and the Government of Canada allowing the settling of their lands without treaty. Thus, due to their extreme grievances that would otherwise tempt the First Nations to enlist, the British Columbian First Nations produced very few recruits in proportion to their population and the smallest financial donation26. The British Columbian First Nations tended to utilize their lack of participation to bring attention to their grievances. Indigenous communities have otherwise been forced into their reserves with little ability to interact with the outside world and it was not until the Indian agent and the recruitment officer came asking for recruits could some tribes be heard by outside agents or negotiate ways to improve their situation.
Indigenous communities and tribes used participation in war to make a statement, one that they would not quietly assimilate, at least not without accommodations for their culture being made. From communities passively protesting participation in the wars to near unanimous support for the war, indigenous communities used participation in the wars to interact with a government that had otherwise refused to negotiate with the indigenous communities. Returning veterans such as Frederick Loft used the respect for indigenous veterans to try and bring unity to an indigenous movement in Canada and founded the League of Indians of Canada27. Had the Canadian Government looked after the indigenous veterans as they had the white veterans the indigenous veterans’ may have been more able to play an active role politically, but many returned to a sustenance based lifestyle that occupied the veterans and their families felt little social change. Despite the returning veterans not bringing back the same financial infusion as their white counterparts, they brought a cultural resurgence that invigorated their communities to seek the social justice they were being denied.
Bibliography
Innes, Robert Alexander. 2007. ""I'm on Home Ground Now. I'm Safe": Saskatchewan Aboriginal Veterans in the immediate Postwar Years, 1945-1946." In Aboriginal Peoples and Military Participation: Canadian & International Perspectives, by P. Whitney Lackenbauer, R. Scott Sheffield and Craig Leslie Mantle, 35-76. Kingston, Ontario: Canadian Defence Academy Press.
Lackenbauer, P. Whitney. 2007. "Introduction." In Aboriginal Peoples and the Canadian Military: Historical Perspectives, by P. Whitney Lackenbauer and Craig Leslie Mantle, xi- xxv. Kingston: Canadian Defence Press.
Lackenbauer, P. Whitney, and Katherine McGowan. 2007. "Competing Loyalties in a Complex Community: Enlisting the Six Nations in the Canadian Expeditionary Force, 1914-1917." In Aboriginal Peoples and the Canadian Military: Historical Perspectives, by P. Whitney Lackenbauer and Craig Leslie Mantle, 89-115. Kingston, Ontario: Canadian Defence Academy Press.
Richard, Holt. 2013. "First Nations Soldiers in the Great War." Native Studies Review 22 (1/2): 139-156.
Scott, D. C. 2007. "The Indians and the Great War." In Aboriginal Peoples and the Canadian Military: Historical Perspective, by P. Whitney Lackenbauer and Craig Leslie Mantle, 73-88. Kingston, Ontario: Canadian Defence Academy Press.
Sheffield, R. Scott. 2007. "Canadian Aboriginal Veterans and the Veterans Charter after the Second World War." In Aboriginal People and the Canadian Military: Canadian and International Perspectives, by P. Whitney Lackenbauer, R. Scott Sheffield and Craig Leslie Mantle, 77-98. Kingston, Ontario: Canadian Defence Academy Press.
Story, Eric. 2015. "The Awakening Has Come." Canadian Military History 24 (2): 11-35.
Talbot, Robert J. 2011. ""It Would Be Best to Leave Us Alone": First Nations Responses to the Canadian War Effort, 1914-18." Journal of Canadian Studies 45 (1): 90-120.
Williams, Jeffery. 2003. Far From Home. Calgary: University of Calgary Press.
Story, Eric, 2015. "The Awakening Has Come." Canadian Military History 24 (2): 14; Holt, Robert, “First Nation Soldiers in the Great War,” Native Studies Review 22, no 1/2 (July 2013) 146.
Scott, D. C., "The Indians and the Great War" In Aboriginal Peoples and the Canadian Military: Historical Perspective, by P. Whitney Lackenbauer and Craig Leslie Mantle, 73-88. Kingston, Ontario (Canadian Defence Academy Press, 2007), 73.
Ibid., 74.
Lackenbauer, P., Whitney, "Introduction." In Aboriginal Peoples and the Canadian Military: Historical Perspectives, by P. Whitney Lackenbauer and Craig Leslie Mantle, xi- xxv. Kingston, Ontario (Canadian Defence Press, 2007.), xv.
Story, 14-15.
Ibid., 16.
Ibid., 14-15.
Ibid., 23.
Williams, Jeffery, Far From Home (Calgary: University of Calgary Press 2003), 190.
Story, 26, 30.
Ibid., 31.
Talbot, Robert J., "It Would Be Best to Leave Us Alone": First Nations Responses to the Canadian War Effort 1914-18.” Journal Of Canadian Studies 45 no. 1 (Winter 2011): 108-109, 112.
Innes, Robert Alexander, “I’m on Home Ground Now. I’m Safe”: Saskatchewan Aboriginal Veterans in the Immediate Postwar Years, 1945-1946”: Aboriginal Peoples and Military Participation: Canadian and International Perspectives, by P. Whitney Lackenbauer, R. Scott Sheffield and Craig Leslie Mantle (Kingston, Ontario: Canadian Defence Academy Press), 41.
Ibid., 43.
Sheffield, R Scott, “Canadian Aboriginal Veterans and the Veterans Charter after the Second World War”: Aboriginal Peoples and Military Participation: Canadian and International Perspectives, by P. Whitney Lackenbauer, R. Scott Sheffield and Craig Leslie Mantle (Kingston, Ontario: Canadian Defence Academy Press), 79.
Ibid., 85.
Talbot, 112.
Lackenbauer, P. Whitney; Katherine McGowan: “Competing Loyalties in a Complex Community: Enlisting the Six Nations in the Canadian Expeditionary Force, 1914-1917.”: Aboriginal Peoples and the Canadian Military: Historical Perspectives, by P Whitney Lackenbauer and Crag Leslie Mantle (Kingston, Ontario: Canadian Defence Academy Press), 97.
Talbot, 94.
Ibid., 94, 99.
Ibid., 96-97.
Ibid., 93, 97-98.
Ibid., 104.
Scott, D. C., "The Indians and the Great War", 84.
Talbot, 105.
Ibid., 112.
Story, 30.