One concept introduced to me in my first university English class was actually a class in which the professor aimed to change the emphasis on literature studies, focusing on the power of narrative versus literature. The question people need to ask is why authors such as George Orwell, Charles Dickens, and others are considered a cut above the rest of the countless amount of authors in the world. Of course, authors such as Guy Vanderhaege and H. G. Wells have incredibly sophisticated well constructed prose and plot and they should be appreciated for that, but what makes their stories more important than those of creative authors or those decided as less sophisticated authors.
Literature as described by the aforementioned professor are [paraphrased] “books decided by guys like me who tell other’s that this book is worth reading,” which is inherently problematic. The emphasis is put upon learned education and creates barriers in that interpretations of alternative forms of story is dismissed or downplayed in lieu of the big authors. Of course the list of literary authors is already daunting for many, and I find new books everyday that would fall into this camp, but that remains the question of popular media.
Quentin Tarantino has a notoriety of being incredibly particular of everything portrayed in his films, and everything has a purpose for being positioned where, and when it appears in the film. While I doubt other directors put the same level of exactitude that Tarantino places upon his movies, but the choice to represent anything in media is more often than not intentional, and when it isn’t intentional, it relies upon cultural understandings which might not always stay an accurate reflection of societies. That being in mind changes how one might engage with a film, as it has ruined many movie night between myself and my partner as I ramble on about how Japanese children’s shows portrays one thing or another (sometimes seemingly unintentionally) or as I hypothesize what we might understand about Japanese society from their media.
Looking more close to home, today we live in the Golden Age of the Marvel cinematic universe. As an entry level-nerd (for many things) I’ve been made aware of earlier comic book Golden and Silver ages, but I think we can all recognize the incredibly high quality of Marvel’s Avengers universe. While we all recognize the quality, we might not recognize the underlying significance of these films. While some older academics might dismiss these films simply as cheap entertainment, as mentioned in another post regarding Black Widow, I analyzed a short 3minute scene of Black Panther, a show in which inverts the traditional colonial narrative and puts an African nation as the one with vastly superior technological capabilities. There are an incredible amount of nuance in how Ryan Coogler interwove this inversion into the film and the portrayal of the Wakkandans, but in an incredibly short paper I looked at the contrasting presentation of London and Wakkanda. I as an academic attempt to make the argument that Wakkanda acts in criticism of London, but a viewer can appreciate the difference in the two architectural styles and perhaps think more deeply of how this portrays the relationship a civilization has with it’s society.
2
Alexander Rousseau
24452147
21 October 2019
Domination and Superiority in Ryan Coogler’s Black Panther
Wakanda, in Ryan Coogler’s Black Panther inverts the narrative of the inferiority of African tribes in comparison to the domination of the world by western colonization and subsequent domination in technology and economy. In an inversion of the presumptions behind Kipling’s White Man’s Burden, the Wakandan society is demanded frequently throughout the film to intervene in global affairs. Coogler establishes the inversion of Wakandan superiority, portrayed by the scene which viewers are first introduced to Wakanda contrasted with the brief scene that immediately follows portraying London. London provides a familiar frame of reference, although happening after, London provides a basic understanding of civilization for viewers. Viewers first see Wakanda when T’Challa’s ship flies over the traditional lands of Wakanda, showing a conventional narrative of traditional herding and remote tribal people ranging over open and unmarred land. Upon penetrating the holographic shroud, the scene presents viewers the central metropolis of Wakanda which reflects a concentration of civilization that is far beyond the western civilization, which dominates outside Wakanda’s isolation. Viewers must questions how the construction that western civilization is superior to indigenous cultures, which Coogler presents the contrary to which indigenous cultures have both a capacity and potential for advanced civilization without the western requirement to impose or control the world.
To contextualize the disparity between western civilization and Wakanda, Coogler offers a transition overlooking London, similar to the presentation of Wakanda. Although more briefly than the presentation of Wakanda, London is shown from an aerial view, scanning the horizon of the far-reaching metropolis. Tall structures dominate the panorama of London as they vary in shape while similarly being built upon a river. There is a domination of the natural world in which the natural environment is non-existent, and the architecture dominates the Thames river, featured prominently in center frame. Thus, London and its familiar architecture give western viewers a familiar frame of reference, something that does not need an extensive fly-over to explain the significance of English sophistication. The London view ends with a transition to the Museum which holds African and Wakandan artifacts. The transitions between Wakanda, London and the Museum suggest a colonial relationship of domination between western civilization and the world. At one point in time, one might recognize London as the center of the civilized world, and Black Panther suggests that Wakanda has lived in isolation of this domination for centuries.
T’Challa announces the nature of the scene when flying through the holographic shroud in which T’Challa states, “This never gets old.” The ship travels over Wakanda, offering a panorama in which one might expect from the presentation of London or other western metropoles, but not of African tribal civilization. Viewers are offered a familiar scene to the western viewer is a metropolis centred around a river, although, in comparison to the London scene, Wakanda lacks bridges compared to London and the bridges that straddle the Thames river. While Wakanda does have bridges, their intrusion on the natural world is minimized, and their effect on the environment seems to be for foot traffic. While bridges might signify a difference between Wakanda and London, they share modern architecture’s skyward thrust in which tall buildings dominate the landscape. Although Wakanda appears to have grander and more sophisticated buildings than London, thus Wakanda holds superiority over the architecture portrayed. Furthermore, considering the disparity in the colour palettes, which is jarring dissimilar from London’s western greys and blues. Wakanda is adorned in adobe browns and greens, as it coexists with nature. Upon closer inspection the usage of what is akin to glass, metal and, concrete is explicit, but some rooves are constructed with a kind of thatch, and the usage of plaster and clays seems more prominent than what would be seen later with the presentation of London which occurs immediately after the landing of T’Challa in Wakanda. While purely fictional, Wakanda is portrayed as a utopia in the cradle of nature, bringing criticism to London, which exists as a synthetic incubator of western civilization.
Throughout the film is a discussion of the role of superiority that civilization has to the rest of the world. While western civilization has chosen the path of domination, utilizing a disparity in arms, organization and transportation to dominate not only people and land but also to control and dominate nature. Coogler’s portray an advanced indigenous civilization that developed a form of civilization that is based on both isolation from global affairs and harmony with nature. The contrasting Wakanda and London suggest that while advanced civilization is inevitable, the application of that civilization is not predetermined. Coogler suggests that an indigenous way of being if applied to civilization, while might look similar, is fundamentally different in application. From a western framework, superiority is often portrayed in the application of a hierarchy and the assertion of superior civilizations. Wakanda offers an alternative narrative in which a society that has far surpassed its peers but acts without the forced domination. Ultimately the conflict between T’Challa and Killmonger is how best to apply that superiority through domination or aid.
Works Cited
Black Panther. Dir. Ryan Coogler. Marvel Studios, 2018. Netflix.
Kipling, Rudyard. "The White Man's Burden." 1899. Kipling Society. <http://www.kiplingsociety.co.uk/poems_burden.htm>.